The Overlooked Private Credit Risk is in Life Insurance

As investors focus on rising redemptions in BDCs and interval funds, cracks and vulnerabilities in the private credit market are beginning to show, including an overlooked risk in the life insurance industry, as Marblegate Managing Partner Andrew Milgram explained in a recent interview with Axios.

 Life insurers have become a primary source of capital for private credit, which the Chicago Fed estimates is nearly half of the $1.8 trillion industry’s assets. A growing share of that capital is being reinvested into related-party investments, in some cases reaching 20-35% of insurer portfolios. At the same time, early signs of stress are emerging. Annuity surrender benefits rose 16.3% in 2024, according to National Association of Insurance Commissioners data, while the IMF found that PE-backed insurers hold fewer liquid assets than their peers, making them more vulnerable to corporate credit default cycles.

Andrew points to how this creates the potential for what he calls a “doom loop,” where concerns over the market lead retirees to “surrender” their annuities, creating more private credit distress and leading to more withdrawals, reinforcing the cycle.We’ve seen this before. Periods of excess liquidity can mask credit deterioration beneath the surface and ultimately increase the severity of the correction. This is an environment that creates compelling opportunities for firms that are uniquely positioned to execute both financial and operational restructurings to stabilize businesses and unlock long-term value.

Read more